Skip to main content

Auditor General report on CARM released today

The Auditor General of Canada released their report on CARM today. 

A report from Auditor General Karen Hogan tabled today in the House of Commons concludes that the Canada Border Services Agency Assessment and Revenue Management (CARM) system processed customs duties and taxes for commercial goods imported into Canada but did not generate the expected efficiencies and value for money. (link)

 

The full report along with an overview of the report can be found here - https://www.canada.ca/en/auditor-general/our-work/audit-reports/23-auditor-general-202610-assessment-revenue-system-imports.html 

 

Key facts and findings

  • The collection of customs duties and taxes on imported commercial goods is the federal government’s second-largest source of revenue after income taxes, totalling around $42 billion in the 2024–25 fiscal year.
  • CARM effectively processed commercial import declarations.
  • CARM has cost about $800 million to develop and maintain but did not work efficiently without manual workarounds.
  • CARM was expected to be deployed in 2021, but this was delayed until October 2024. Delays in developing CARM meant that the agency had to retain project staff longer than expected, leading to an increase in development costs and budget.
  • The agency used about $88 million from its non‑CARM budget to fund CARM maintenance and upgrade costs.
  • The agency did not establish service level standards to correct incidents, such as software errors, slow performance, or other issues affecting users’ ability to access services or complete their work.
  • Most performance indicators were not designed to measure CARM’s benefits to Canadians. As a result, the Canada Border Services Agency is not positioned to assess whether CARM is providing the value for money that was expected.
  • CARM is a system that relies on importers to self-declare; however, the Canada Border Services Agency did not sufficiently support importers in the use of the system prior to deployment. 

 

 

Topic(s)

CBSA Assessment and Revenue Management (CARM)
Disclaimer

The foregoing information is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended as, nor should it be considered, professional advice or a substitute for conducting your own thorough research and review. Before making any decisions or taking any action based on the information provided, you should conduct your own independent investigation and/or seek professional advice from a qualified expert in the relevant field. The CSCB disclaims all liability for actions taken or not taken based on the information provided.